|
is this normal?
I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car
and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. Why is this? Or is it normal? |
Re: is this normal?
You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you
from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or did it just sounds making it? "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you
from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or did it just sounds making it? "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you
from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or did it just sounds making it? "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i
noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound right. "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or > did it just sounds making it? > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i
noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound right. "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or > did it just sounds making it? > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i
noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound right. "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound or > did it just sounds making it? > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
A lot of cars do that. As stated, it's the shift release. Don't worry
about it. "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
A lot of cars do that. As stated, it's the shift release. Don't worry
about it. "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
A lot of cars do that. As stated, it's the shift release. Don't worry
about it. "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
It is actually a solenoid, not a relay.
electricked wrote: > > Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that > switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and > works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and > see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of > like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. > > --Viktor > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > > right. > > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent > you > > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal > though, > > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the > sound > > or > > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > > car > > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > > at. > > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
It is actually a solenoid, not a relay.
electricked wrote: > > Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that > switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and > works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and > see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of > like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. > > --Viktor > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > > right. > > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent > you > > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal > though, > > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the > sound > > or > > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > > car > > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > > at. > > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
It is actually a solenoid, not a relay.
electricked wrote: > > Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that > switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and > works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and > see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of > like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. > > --Viktor > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > > right. > > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent > you > > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal > though, > > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the > sound > > or > > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > > car > > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > > at. > > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
thanks guys for the help.
"amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
thanks guys for the help.
"amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
thanks guys for the help.
"amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the car > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is at. > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that
switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. --Viktor "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that
switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. --Viktor "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yeah, it's normal. I have the same sound on my 98 accord. It's a relay that
switches on and off depending if you're holding the pedal up or down and works in the way the previous poster described. You can even open it up and see exactly where the relay is (relay is an elecromagnetic switch). Kind of like a transistor but it uses different principles to switch on/off. --Viktor "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message news:UtTYb.4555$iB.775@lakeread06... > no i had it for awhile i also put a different gear shifter on it. But i > noticed it for awhile but wasnt sure if its normal. Like i said i tap the > brake pedal and sounds like somewthings hitting that stick but you sound > right. > "Sean D" <nospam@nospam.ca> wrote in message > news:bcTYb.99826$IF6.2899932@ursa-nb00s0.nbnet.nb.ca... > > You're hearing the shift release. That is the mechanism that prevent you > > from shifting out of park without having the break pedal pressed. I've > > heard that sounds on older accords before. As far as being normal though, > > I'm not sure. Did you just buy the car and are wondering about the sound > or > > did it just sounds making it? > > > > "amsjsj" <amsjsj@cox.net> wrote in message > > news:lYSYb.4546$iB.1718@lakeread06... > > > I have a an 96 accord lx non vtec, automatic. When I put my key in the > car > > > and tap on the brakes theres a clicking sound in where the shifter is > at. > > > Why is this? Or is it normal? > > > > > > > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
"Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message
news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. Same thing. --Viktor |
Re: is this normal?
"Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message
news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. Same thing. --Viktor |
Re: is this normal?
"Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message
news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. Same thing. --Viktor |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > Same thing. > > --Viktor No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather picayune but there is a difference. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > Same thing. > > --Viktor No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather picayune but there is a difference. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > Same thing. > > --Viktor No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather picayune but there is a difference. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same.
They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do about solenoids. --Viktor "Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:10392qg5nu4dj32@corp.supernews.com... > > > "electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message > news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > > > Same thing. > > > > --Viktor > No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical > (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by > definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component > (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both > perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather > picayune but there is a difference. > > Dave D > -- > Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same.
They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do about solenoids. --Viktor "Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:10392qg5nu4dj32@corp.supernews.com... > > > "electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message > news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > > > Same thing. > > > > --Viktor > No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical > (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by > definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component > (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both > perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather > picayune but there is a difference. > > Dave D > -- > Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same.
They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do about solenoids. --Viktor "Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:10392qg5nu4dj32@corp.supernews.com... > > > "electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message > news:JYOdna4qt87WpKndRVn_iw@comcast.com... > > "Randolph" <trash@junkmail.com> wrote in message > > news:40341D0D.E78DAF11@junkmail.com... > > > It is actually a solenoid, not a relay. > > > > Same thing. > > > > --Viktor > No, Viktor, they are not the same thing. A switch can be either mechanical > (relay) or purely electrical (as some transistors are) but a solenoid (by > definition) must incorporate both an electrical and a mechanical component > (such as the actuating mechanism on an auto starter). I agree that both > perform the same basic function and that the difference is really rather > picayune but there is a difference. > > Dave D > -- > Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! > > > > > > |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:bNednb1wDu4Du6jdRVn-vg@comcast.com... > Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same. > They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little > different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I > mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do > about solenoids. > > --Viktor From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I am sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is important. Keep up the good work. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:bNednb1wDu4Du6jdRVn-vg@comcast.com... > Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same. > They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little > different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I > mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do > about solenoids. > > --Viktor From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I am sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is important. Keep up the good work. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! |
Re: is this normal?
"electricked" <no_emails_please> wrote in message news:bNednb1wDu4Du6jdRVn-vg@comcast.com... > Yes, Dave. I agree. I meant it in terms of practical use they are the same. > They both do the same thing. Of course their mechanisms are a little > different but that's not important for this discussion. The reason I > mentioned relay is because most people know more about relays than they do > about solenoids. > > --Viktor From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I am sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is important. Keep up the good work. Dave D -- Hunt hard...Kill quick...Offer No Apologies! |
Re: is this normal?
"Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:103bf7nd0i68l48@corp.supernews.com... > From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant > but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before > certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I've been around, I know the risks, trust me ;) > I am > sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they > think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable I agree. In order for people to relate, you have to mention the more used term and I'd think more people know/think they know what a relay is compared to a solenoid. I'm sure you understand. > rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical > correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is > important. Right. Technical advice is good for people who want to learn or might have tech background. If someone wants to get a quick-fix I don't give them all the tech-talk unless they specifically ask for it. I agree with you though. This newsgroup is about learning and tech-talk is preferable. Glad you pointed that out. Keep the information flowing. That's why we're here afterall! --Viktor |
Re: is this normal?
"Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:103bf7nd0i68l48@corp.supernews.com... > From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant > but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before > certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I've been around, I know the risks, trust me ;) > I am > sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they > think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable I agree. In order for people to relate, you have to mention the more used term and I'd think more people know/think they know what a relay is compared to a solenoid. I'm sure you understand. > rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical > correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is > important. Right. Technical advice is good for people who want to learn or might have tech background. If someone wants to get a quick-fix I don't give them all the tech-talk unless they specifically ask for it. I agree with you though. This newsgroup is about learning and tech-talk is preferable. Glad you pointed that out. Keep the information flowing. That's why we're here afterall! --Viktor |
Re: is this normal?
"Dave Dodson" <ddodson@gci.net> wrote in message news:103bf7nd0i68l48@corp.supernews.com... > From your other posts, Viktor, I was fairly certain that was what you meant > but I thought I would get a kinder, gentler disagreement put in before > certain others here attacked with vigor! (Hehe, if you get my meaning). I've been around, I know the risks, trust me ;) > I am > sure that more are familiar with relays than solenoids (or at least they > think they are) because they use the term relay and solenoid interchangable I agree. In order for people to relate, you have to mention the more used term and I'd think more people know/think they know what a relay is compared to a solenoid. I'm sure you understand. > rather than correctly but you are correct in the fact that the technical > correct term should take second place to the function as that is what is > important. Right. Technical advice is good for people who want to learn or might have tech background. If someone wants to get a quick-fix I don't give them all the tech-talk unless they specifically ask for it. I agree with you though. This newsgroup is about learning and tech-talk is preferable. Glad you pointed that out. Keep the information flowing. That's why we're here afterall! --Viktor |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:57 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands