Rep Power: 863

Johnston & Magwood –Unprofessional Tire Care


I’ve dealt with Johnston and Magwood in Mississauga about 4 times in 5 years. I’ve spent from $600 - $1500 on tires each visit. So I’ve been there a few times, spent some money and was treated very well the first 2 times and figure “hey, they’ll treat me right because I spend money”……….nope, read on
About 2 years ago I had went to Johnston and Magwood with the wife. She was getting new tires put on her rims, not a huge deal. Though I don’t remember the details 100% of what happened I do remember being pissed at the way the installer was talking to my wife and to myself. I was so upset that I manned up and spoke to the manager at the time. He blew it off as a misunderstanding and finalized it with a “not my problem” attitude at the end.
Fine, I left pissed off, told myself never to go back and made a forum post on that useless local mustang site (which of course the post got deleted). Time went on, the world didn’t stop turning blah blah blah (but the mustang site remained useless).
Fast forward to (January 5 2007). I call our sponsors, not in; 2nd time I’ve called, once for rims and once for tires. So I start making calls for some new rubber for the Mustang. It’s been about 2 years since dealing with Johnston and Magwood so I call them. I speak to Neil and get some quotes on Kumhos / Fusion, discuss sizing then inquire about drag radials for the rear. Neil tells me he can get them, but they will be around $350 each, exact brand I don’t recall nor did I make note, I just needed a drag radial. Drag radials were an after thought to the goal of getting 4 17” 40 series tires.
Fast forward to this morning. I round up my truck, grab a business associate and go for a cruise to Johnston and Magwood to order these tires up. We discuss my previous dealings with the shop, chuckle about it but all agree it will be ok; I had a good feeling after talking to Neil.

Quick thought…..The real deciding factor to deal with them, they can mount on chrome and do 40 series no problem.

We drive for about 35 minutes, arrive onsite and begin our lobby waiting until we can be assisted. An Asian lady comes flying in looking for directions to the library, interrupts Sal (manager I find out later) and he quickly puts her in her place with a “I’m busy with a customer”. So Sal and Neil work on this disgruntled customer who murmurs something about not wanting to rent a car for 2 weeks over this problem he has. Sal snaped back he had a solution for the guy and “im doing it as a courtesy”. Half the story is all I got, but it didn’t sound good from the customers annoyed pitch and Sals rude response.
My associate and I assist the Asian lady and point her in the right direction (customer service point for us). Sal breaks free and offers us assistance. I inquire about purchasing some tires; Mickey Thompson or drag radials. Sal responds “we don’t sell them here, we sell high performance tires”. So right away I think did these idiots just tell me last night they can get drag radials and today they’re saying no. The thought must have ran through my head the instance he finished with the “we sell high performance tires”. No offer for other solutions from Sal, not even a “we carry x brand drag radial”, nothing, just a business deal killer.
I leave now knowing that a) they don’t sell MT or Drag Radials, b) they only sell high performance tires.. c) Johnston and Magwood has really lousy customer service.
After a quick stop at two other shops to get pricing I head home. No buying today, because no pricing and nothing in stock. Was ok, Johnston and Magwood according to Neil would only be able to have the tires in come Monday.

I start composing this because I want to make sure my friends on these websites are aware of the problems that happen there at Johnston and Magwood. I start thinking, hey, the right thing to do is call and tell them I’m displeased. I call at about 12:15 pm and first speak with Neil. Conversation as expected, he’s the front man and doesn’t have much to say. I know its not his fault and im assuming even if there was something to be done about it, he’s not the guy. I ask who the shorter white guy was and Neil tells me Sal. So I ask who the manager is, “Sal”. So, Sal gets on the phone and we start discussing the problem at hand. (he confirmed they sell DR's, not MT)
From his angle, who’s at fault for our lil customer service debacle? Was it me because I walked out fast without inquiring about “what else can you sell me”. Or was it Sals’ shortness with me and lack of wanting to offer up more options.
Sal said sorry, I accepted and I told him I would still review my experience with his shop and post it once again (except this time no useless can delete it).

So, my overall point. Yes, Johnston and Magwood can do nice work, but so can many other shops out there. Johnston and Magwoods’ customer service is **** poor and from my last two dealings, nothing has changed. I will avoid them in the future and I suggest others do to. There are many other shops out there that would love to take your money and be helpful and respectful, even informative.
It bums me out that places like this treat people so shitty.

GREAT MUSTANG SITE WHERE THEY WONT BAN YOU FOR POSTING THE TRUTH :thumbsup: Shameless plug for my buddy

 
Rep Power: 718

Wow thats quite the story,they sell tires I dont understand why they did not take the oppurtunaty to make a sale instead of pissing you off.

 
Rep Power: 863

I rarely ever use these sites to slam a business. And i've had much done wrong to me in my lifetime.. LOL

But, disrespecting my wife and biting my tongue back then was hard enough (she told me to be nice), and now totally being rude again, unreal. Live and learn. F them.

I mean, i even said to Sal, why not offer me other solutions ? But he didnt want to, thats the problem.

I mean, i was courteous enough to call them and let them know this would be posted, i wanted to give him a chance to explain.

Miscommunication is pretty much where he was going with it. I think he was just being plain out rude.

But its funny, this is the 2nd time ive posted about them. Ive never publicly ripped a business before aside from them (or atleast recall doing so) in at least 7 years (jog my memory if i have).. LOL

 
Rep Power: 749

Sorry about your luck. I remember the original story from back in the day.

 
Rep Power: 713

I have not really dealt with them since Mike the old counter sales guy left.
Neil is not a bad guy but I think new management and ownership has
doomed that company. They used to own the whole building, now its
all sub divided because their buisiness has fallen off IMO.

 
Rep Power: 786

I have found them to be pricey!!!!!!!

 
Rep Power: 721

You guys are too far west for me to know that shop.

Here in the east, my favourite tire shop is 2nd Time Around....they sell rims, rubber, do Alignments.....and they do REAL good work and they are very helpful.

I don't trust alot of people working on my car....nobody infact, other than myself, my dad....and one of the mechanics at 2nd time around simply because they explain exactly what they are going to do before they do anything. And since I know cars, I know they're not bullshitting me.....but I've heard them with other customers and it's the same deal, anything that a cutomer doesn't understand, they explain it as best as possible.

And thier prices on stuff is reasonable which is nice.

 
Rep Power: 863

I have found them to have not gotten my business on the purchase. More later once they're in, with pics

 
Rep Power: 0

If your in Etobicoke, on Kipling there is Kipling Tire north of the Queensway.I drive a 86 GT.