Ivan Demkovitch

Problem existed for a while (about a year)
I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging system...

Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced it with new
one.
So, I don't think its related....

"w_tom" <w_tom1@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3F74FD6D.56815EAA@hotmail.com...
> Why was your battery replaced? Because charging system is
> not working properly? The only way to answer Tony Hwang's
> question is to measure vehicle system voltage. New battery
> would not solve the problem. Defective battery would be
> another symptom of that same problem.
>
> Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> > Tony,
> >
> > I thought same thing before. But no, my battery is brand new
> > (replaced week ago) It didn't change a thing...
> >
> > "Tony Hwang" <dragon40@shaw.ca> wrote in message
> > newsh6db.28218$TM4.19681@pd7tw2no...
> >> Hi,
> >> Do you have a good battery holding a good charge?
> >> Wonder if you have a weak battery or charging system.
> >> Tony

w_tom

Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
common factor would be the system voltage.

BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
(charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> system...
>
> Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> it with new one.
> So, I don't think its related....

w_tom

Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
common factor would be the system voltage.

BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
(charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> system...
>
> Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> it with new one.
> So, I don't think its related....

w_tom

Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
common factor would be the system voltage.

BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
(charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> system...
>
> Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> it with new one.
> So, I don't think its related....

Ivan Demkovitch

Thanks.

Will check voltage first to make sure.

BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...



"w_tom" <w_tom1@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3F7617D2.D34A4865@hotmail.com...
> Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
> But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
> involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
> common factor would be the system voltage.
>
> BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
> when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
> nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
> voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
> engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
> peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
> (charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
> voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.
>
> Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> > Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> > I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> > system...
> >
> > Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> > it with new one.
> > So, I don't think its related....

Ivan Demkovitch

Thanks.

Will check voltage first to make sure.

BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...



"w_tom" <w_tom1@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3F7617D2.D34A4865@hotmail.com...
> Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
> But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
> involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
> common factor would be the system voltage.
>
> BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
> when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
> nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
> voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
> engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
> peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
> (charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
> voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.
>
> Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> > Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> > I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> > system...
> >
> > Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> > it with new one.
> > So, I don't think its related....

Ivan Demkovitch

Thanks.

Will check voltage first to make sure.

BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...



"w_tom" <w_tom1@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:3F7617D2.D34A4865@hotmail.com...
> Granted we are speculating without sufficient information.
> But a few facts. Delay of lights and delay of wipers would
> involve separate electrical systems or relays. The only
> common factor would be the system voltage.
>
> BTW, my Honda batteries never lasted less than 7 years even
> when always parked outside. Last battery went something over
> nine years. It may just be me. But still, until system
> voltage reading are taken with a digital multimeter (with
> engine off, with engine on, and with engine on and every
> peripheral on), then we cannot eliminate system voltage
> (charging system) from a list of possibilities. System
> voltage is the one common factor to 'strange' symptoms.
>
> Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> > Problem existed for a while (about a year)
> > I don't think battery would work for that long with bad charging
> > system...
> >
> > Battery was 4.5 years old and it just died last week. I replaced
> > it with new one.
> > So, I don't think its related....

w_tom

In every case, the battery was original from Honda. One was
even a Delco battery.

Do be sure to report back. Your's is an interesting
problem.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Thanks.
>
> Will check voltage first to make sure.
>
> BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
> cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...

w_tom

In every case, the battery was original from Honda. One was
even a Delco battery.

Do be sure to report back. Your's is an interesting
problem.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Thanks.
>
> Will check voltage first to make sure.
>
> BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
> cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...

w_tom

In every case, the battery was original from Honda. One was
even a Delco battery.

Do be sure to report back. Your's is an interesting
problem.

Ivan Demkovitch wrote:
> Thanks.
>
> Will check voltage first to make sure.
>
> BTW, you probably use good batteries. Any battery I bought (and I buy
> cheaper batteeries) never lasted more then 5-6 years...