Price Gougeing
09-02-2005, 01:09 AM
#16
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Seth" <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny...
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:y1uRe.3505$rj.1918@lakeread07...
>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and fills
>> it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to the public
>> is $1.00 per gal.
>>
>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the 4000
>> gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>
>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining 1000
>> gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a gal, they
>> raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the under ground
>> tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals. Then they lie to us
>> saying they only make penny's on the gal profit,bullshit!
>
> I was quite pleasantly surprised yesterday (after getting over the shock
> of how much everyone was raising prices) by the behavior of my towns local
> Mobil station.
>
> Yesterday afternoon, the Gulf on the corner raised it's prices to $2.999.
> I was in the Cumberland Farms a few doors down getting a few items when I
> noticed the line, 20 cars long for the Mobil station. When I asked the
> clerk of the store I was in what was going on, he told me the owner of the
> Mobil station stated he was not going to change his price ($2.699) until
> his tanks ran dry, then raise his price to match what his next refill cost
> him. I thought that was admirable. Today he has cones up blocking his
> pumps as he is empty.
>
> So I continued on my way, and a half mile down the road I passed the local
> Stewart's Shop. They are usually one of the cheapest places around.
> Their price was already bumped up to $3.299.
>
> On my way home later that night, the above mentioned Gulf station was up
> to $3.19.
>
> Today, while heading to Home Depot and my buddies bagel shop up in
> Poughkeepsie, I saw EVERY Mobil station on Rt 9 with their price at
> $2.899. On my way home as I passed the same Stewart's Shop their price was
> $3.499. What the hell makes their gas worth $.60 more than Mobil???
>
> So I called my buddy who owned the bagel shop and asked him what prices he
> saw for gas on his way home (he lives in New Paltz). Of the 3 Mobil
> stations, 2 were at $2.999 (including the one right off the exit for the
> NYS Thruway which is usually a little higher than everybody else due to
> it's location) but this 1 Mobil station (on Rt 9W just north of Highland)
> they also had their price cranked up to $3.499.
>
> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
>
Since there is no advantage in being more expensive than a nearby competitor
for a commodity (and having to advertise the price so prominently to get any
customers at all), I'd expect it means the wholesaler's price already went
up and their truck has already delivered the expensive stuff. All the
overpriced stations can realistically do is to wait until the others sell
out or have to restock at the higher price.
Mike
news:XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny...
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:y1uRe.3505$rj.1918@lakeread07...
>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and fills
>> it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to the public
>> is $1.00 per gal.
>>
>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the 4000
>> gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>
>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining 1000
>> gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a gal, they
>> raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the under ground
>> tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals. Then they lie to us
>> saying they only make penny's on the gal profit,bullshit!
>
> I was quite pleasantly surprised yesterday (after getting over the shock
> of how much everyone was raising prices) by the behavior of my towns local
> Mobil station.
>
> Yesterday afternoon, the Gulf on the corner raised it's prices to $2.999.
> I was in the Cumberland Farms a few doors down getting a few items when I
> noticed the line, 20 cars long for the Mobil station. When I asked the
> clerk of the store I was in what was going on, he told me the owner of the
> Mobil station stated he was not going to change his price ($2.699) until
> his tanks ran dry, then raise his price to match what his next refill cost
> him. I thought that was admirable. Today he has cones up blocking his
> pumps as he is empty.
>
> So I continued on my way, and a half mile down the road I passed the local
> Stewart's Shop. They are usually one of the cheapest places around.
> Their price was already bumped up to $3.299.
>
> On my way home later that night, the above mentioned Gulf station was up
> to $3.19.
>
> Today, while heading to Home Depot and my buddies bagel shop up in
> Poughkeepsie, I saw EVERY Mobil station on Rt 9 with their price at
> $2.899. On my way home as I passed the same Stewart's Shop their price was
> $3.499. What the hell makes their gas worth $.60 more than Mobil???
>
> So I called my buddy who owned the bagel shop and asked him what prices he
> saw for gas on his way home (he lives in New Paltz). Of the 3 Mobil
> stations, 2 were at $2.999 (including the one right off the exit for the
> NYS Thruway which is usually a little higher than everybody else due to
> it's location) but this 1 Mobil station (on Rt 9W just north of Highland)
> they also had their price cranked up to $3.499.
>
> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
>
Since there is no advantage in being more expensive than a nearby competitor
for a commodity (and having to advertise the price so prominently to get any
customers at all), I'd expect it means the wholesaler's price already went
up and their truck has already delivered the expensive stuff. All the
overpriced stations can realistically do is to wait until the others sell
out or have to restock at the higher price.
Mike
09-02-2005, 10:06 AM
#17
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
news:m_JRe.3551$rj.1289@lakeread07...
> Brian , you are right my point is this, the gas stations say they only
> make pennys of profit per gal, I think they are making 100% profit, on a
> certain amount of the gasoline in there tanks, if you read my first post.
I agree with you there Tom. We used to have regulation on gas prices here
years ago. When the world price changed it took ninety days for that
increase to be seen at the pumps (that was the time 'they' said it took for
the old stock to be depleted). Then when the new stock entered the system,
the price rose to reflect that fact. Now-a-days if someone sneezes or blinks
the price changes (rises) immediately. It's not right at all.
Then again, 'they' say that they have to charge the increased price to be
able to pay the increased price when their present stock is depleted, which
makes sense. BUT, the only price that changes immediately when the world
price of oil changes is when the price goes UP! When the world price drops
the price at the pump does NOT reflect that price change immediately, or
even in the weeks that follow the drop. In fact for an increase in the world
price of a dollar a barrel, the price at the pumps here rises six to eight
cents a litre. When the price drops a couple of dollars a barrel the price
at the pumps drop a penny a litre.
I wish I owned stock in an oil company or two!
Brian
09-02-2005, 10:09 AM
#18
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"N.E.Ohio Bob" <rgstroud@neo.rr.com> wrote in message
news:aEHRe.83227$gB.73208@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com.. .
>
> I was just talking to my friend who has an independent Honda-Acura repair
> shop. His price for the next 55 gallon drum of 5W30 is going to be more.
> He will be charging the higher price on the half barrel that is now in his
> shop. He will need the extra money to pay for the NEXT barrel.
> That's the way it has always worked. If you think you can do it better,
> open your own store and try it your way.
> There's an old joke that goes like this; Two brothers from Ohio drive to
> Kentucky and fill their truck with watermelons for a dollar apiece. They
> drive back to Ohio and sell them for a dollar each. When they sold the
> last one, they figure out what they just did. One brother says to the
> other "We need to get a bigger truck." bob
LOL! That's a fact! {;^0
09-02-2005, 11:13 AM
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Brian Smith" <Halifax@NovaScotia.Canada> wrote in
news:k%YRe.252902$on1.223955@clgrps13:
>
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:m_JRe.3551$rj.1289@lakeread07...
>> Brian , you are right my point is this, the gas stations say they
>> only make pennys of profit per gal, I think they are making 100%
>> profit, on a certain amount of the gasoline in there tanks, if you
>> read my first post.
>
> I agree with you there Tom. We used to have regulation on gas prices
> here years ago.
Trudeau copied Nixon's wage and price controls in 1975. It was such a
horrific mistake it was repealed later that year. Trudeau was such a dolt.
He obviously did not learn anything from Nixon's own mistake two years
before.
If Nova Scotia had its own price regulation, I'll bet your prices were far
higher than provinces that did not.
I notice even now, you're paying about 25˘ more per liter than we are in
Ontario. Your taxes must be higher (snicker).
> When the world price changed it took ninety days for
> that increase to be seen at the pumps (that was the time 'they' said
> it took for the old stock to be depleted). Then when the new stock
> entered the system, the price rose to reflect that fact. Now-a-days if
> someone sneezes or blinks the price changes (rises) immediately. It's
> not right at all.
Why not? Can you explain?
<snip>
>
> I wish I owned stock in an oil company or two!
You can easily do that through mutual funds. Oil companies are making
pretty good money now (~10% net), but that could change in an instant,
which is exactly what has happened in the past, and then they'll be down to
7% margins again.
An interesting chart:
http://www.tegger.com/hondafaq/misc/oilprice.jpg
Oil is still WAY cheaper than it was during Nixon's price controls. Reagan
deregulated oil prices in 1982. See that price drop immediately thereafter?
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
news:k%YRe.252902$on1.223955@clgrps13:
>
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:m_JRe.3551$rj.1289@lakeread07...
>> Brian , you are right my point is this, the gas stations say they
>> only make pennys of profit per gal, I think they are making 100%
>> profit, on a certain amount of the gasoline in there tanks, if you
>> read my first post.
>
> I agree with you there Tom. We used to have regulation on gas prices
> here years ago.
Trudeau copied Nixon's wage and price controls in 1975. It was such a
horrific mistake it was repealed later that year. Trudeau was such a dolt.
He obviously did not learn anything from Nixon's own mistake two years
before.
If Nova Scotia had its own price regulation, I'll bet your prices were far
higher than provinces that did not.
I notice even now, you're paying about 25˘ more per liter than we are in
Ontario. Your taxes must be higher (snicker).
> When the world price changed it took ninety days for
> that increase to be seen at the pumps (that was the time 'they' said
> it took for the old stock to be depleted). Then when the new stock
> entered the system, the price rose to reflect that fact. Now-a-days if
> someone sneezes or blinks the price changes (rises) immediately. It's
> not right at all.
Why not? Can you explain?
<snip>
>
> I wish I owned stock in an oil company or two!
You can easily do that through mutual funds. Oil companies are making
pretty good money now (~10% net), but that could change in an instant,
which is exactly what has happened in the past, and then they'll be down to
7% margins again.
An interesting chart:
http://www.tegger.com/hondafaq/misc/oilprice.jpg
Oil is still WAY cheaper than it was during Nixon's price controls. Reagan
deregulated oil prices in 1982. See that price drop immediately thereafter?
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
09-02-2005, 11:34 AM
#20
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Brian Smith" <Halifax@NovaScotia.Canada> wrote
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote
> > Brian , you are right my point is this, the gas stations say they only
> > make pennys of profit per gal, I think they are making 100% profit, on a
> > certain amount of the gasoline in there tanks, if you read my first
post.
>
> I agree with you there Tom. We used to have regulation on gas prices here
> years ago. When the world price changed it took ninety days for that
> increase to be seen at the pumps (that was the time 'they' said it took
for
> the old stock to be depleted). Then when the new stock entered the system,
> the price rose to reflect that fact. Now-a-days if someone sneezes or
blinks
> the price changes (rises) immediately. It's not right at all.
>
> Then again, 'they' say that they have to charge the increased price to be
> able to pay the increased price when their present stock is depleted,
which
> makes sense. BUT, the only price that changes immediately when the world
> price of oil changes is when the price goes UP! When the world price drops
> the price at the pump does NOT reflect that price change immediately, or
> even in the weeks that follow the drop. In fact for an increase in the
world
> price of a dollar a barrel, the price at the pumps here rises six to eight
> cents a litre. When the price drops a couple of dollars a barrel the price
> at the pumps drop a penny a litre.
>
> I wish I owned stock in an oil company or two!
Correct. If one cannot beat 'em, then join 'em. It's part of my financial
strategy lately, hypocritcal as some of its aspects are. I rationalize that,
as I drive my 40 mpg Honda Civic around town, while others drive incredibly
wasteful trucks and SUVs, I may as well profit from their stupidity.
I don't understand the outrage here, myself. Dealers charge way more than
independent shops. Medical fees vary just as much from one hospital or
doctor to another. Etc.
There are important laws on price gouging, but I don't think they kick in at
this point. These gasoline sales businesses are doing what the free market
allows.
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote
> > Brian , you are right my point is this, the gas stations say they only
> > make pennys of profit per gal, I think they are making 100% profit, on a
> > certain amount of the gasoline in there tanks, if you read my first
post.
>
> I agree with you there Tom. We used to have regulation on gas prices here
> years ago. When the world price changed it took ninety days for that
> increase to be seen at the pumps (that was the time 'they' said it took
for
> the old stock to be depleted). Then when the new stock entered the system,
> the price rose to reflect that fact. Now-a-days if someone sneezes or
blinks
> the price changes (rises) immediately. It's not right at all.
>
> Then again, 'they' say that they have to charge the increased price to be
> able to pay the increased price when their present stock is depleted,
which
> makes sense. BUT, the only price that changes immediately when the world
> price of oil changes is when the price goes UP! When the world price drops
> the price at the pump does NOT reflect that price change immediately, or
> even in the weeks that follow the drop. In fact for an increase in the
world
> price of a dollar a barrel, the price at the pumps here rises six to eight
> cents a litre. When the price drops a couple of dollars a barrel the price
> at the pumps drop a penny a litre.
>
> I wish I owned stock in an oil company or two!
Correct. If one cannot beat 'em, then join 'em. It's part of my financial
strategy lately, hypocritcal as some of its aspects are. I rationalize that,
as I drive my 40 mpg Honda Civic around town, while others drive incredibly
wasteful trucks and SUVs, I may as well profit from their stupidity.
I don't understand the outrage here, myself. Dealers charge way more than
independent shops. Medical fees vary just as much from one hospital or
doctor to another. Etc.
There are important laws on price gouging, but I don't think they kick in at
this point. These gasoline sales businesses are doing what the free market
allows.
09-02-2005, 11:36 AM
#21
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"TeGGeR®" <tegger@tegger.c0m> wrote in message
news:Xns96C5722B6F16Btegger@207.14.113.17...
>
> Trudeau copied Nixon's wage and price controls in 1975. It was such a
> horrific mistake it was repealed later that year. Trudeau was such a dolt.
> He obviously did not learn anything from Nixon's own mistake two years
> before.
Trudeau was one of the worst things to have ever happened to Canada. We
continue to suffer to this day and well into the future because of that man
(seems a bit too nice a word to describe him).
> If Nova Scotia had its own price regulation, I'll bet your prices were far
> higher than provinces that did not.
I honestly say that I did not pay any attention to the rest of the country's
prices at that time. Mainly because I was just too young to care and I
didn't travel outside of the Maritimes at the time.
> I notice even now, you're paying about 25˘ more per liter than we are in
> Ontario. Your taxes must be higher (snicker).
We're usually between 15˘ and 20˘ a litre higher than the price in Ontario.
I believe we need to build a pipeline from you to us, so that we can have
some of that cheaper Alberta oil <g>.
On a more disheartening note, the radio staions here just announced that
some gas stations are now selling regular self serve for 148.9˘ a litre.
> Why not? Can you explain?
It's just my feeling that we're being robbed and that it's legal to do it
this way (with the government helping out as much as they can with the crime
<g>).
> You can easily do that through mutual funds. Oil companies are making
> pretty good money now (~10% net), but that could change in an instant,
> which is exactly what has happened in the past, and then they'll be down
> to
> 7% margins again.
I know, but I have to purchase some fuel today to go to work.
> An interesting chart:
> http://www.tegger.com/hondafaq/misc/oilprice.jpg
>
> Oil is still WAY cheaper than it was during Nixon's price controls. Reagan
> deregulated oil prices in 1982. See that price drop immediately
> thereafter?
I have to say that, you and your very comprehensive site are thorough.
Brian
09-02-2005, 02:07 PM
#22
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
In article <XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny>, "Seth" <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> writes:
>
> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
I see no great mystery here.
- Gas is sometimes sold as a loss leader, particularly by stations
attached to convenience stores, as the profit margins for convenience
stores are relatively generous.
- A gas station owner with some cash to burn might well embark on a
little price war, particularly when prices peak, to put some pressure
on competitors.
- During a surge in gas prices, it may be profitable in the long run
to sell gas at a loss in order to build customer loyalty.
These all boil down to the simple principle that it sometimes makes
economic sense to sell a product at a loss for a short period.
Happens all the time, and a "crisis" is an ideal time to do it, since
you get free advertising from media attention and word of mouth.
--
Michael Wojcik michael.wojcik@microfocus.com
Unlikely prediction o' the day:
Eventually, every programmer will have to write a Java or distributed
object program.
-- Orfali and Harkey, _Client / Server Programming with Java and CORBA_
09-02-2005, 03:10 PM
#23
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Seth" <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny...
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:y1uRe.3505$rj.1918@lakeread07...
>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and fills
>> it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to the public
>> is $1.00 per gal.
>>
>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the 4000
>> gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>
>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining 1000
>> gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a gal, they
>> raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the under ground
>> tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals. Then they lie to us
>> saying they only make penny's on the gal profit,bullshit!
>
> I was quite pleasantly surprised yesterday (after getting over the shock
> of how much everyone was raising prices) by the behavior of my towns local
> Mobil station.
>
> Yesterday afternoon, the Gulf on the corner raised it's prices to $2.999.
> I was in the Cumberland Farms a few doors down getting a few items when I
> noticed the line, 20 cars long for the Mobil station. When I asked the
> clerk of the store I was in what was going on, he told me the owner of the
> Mobil station stated he was not going to change his price ($2.699) until
> his tanks ran dry, then raise his price to match what his next refill cost
> him. I thought that was admirable. Today he has cones up blocking his
> pumps as he is empty.
>
> So I continued on my way, and a half mile down the road I passed the local
> Stewart's Shop. They are usually one of the cheapest places around.
> Their price was already bumped up to $3.299.
>
> On my way home later that night, the above mentioned Gulf station was up
> to $3.19.
>
> Today, while heading to Home Depot and my buddies bagel shop up in
> Poughkeepsie, I saw EVERY Mobil station on Rt 9 with their price at
> $2.899. On my way home as I passed the same Stewart's Shop their price was
> $3.499. What the hell makes their gas worth $.60 more than Mobil???
>
> So I called my buddy who owned the bagel shop and asked him what prices he
> saw for gas on his way home (he lives in New Paltz). Of the 3 Mobil
> stations, 2 were at $2.999 (including the one right off the exit for the
> NYS Thruway which is usually a little higher than everybody else due to
> it's location) but this 1 Mobil station (on Rt 9W just north of Highland)
> they also had their price cranked up to $3.499.
>
> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
Well, the above mentioned Mobil station has gas once again and their price
is holding at $2.899. The Gulf next door has since raised prices again and
is now at $3.299 as is the Sunoco up the road. The Stewart's Shop is still
at $3.499.
news:XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny...
> "twfsa" <uksatw@qwest.net> wrote in message
> news:y1uRe.3505$rj.1918@lakeread07...
>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and fills
>> it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to the public
>> is $1.00 per gal.
>>
>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the 4000
>> gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>
>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining 1000
>> gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a gal, they
>> raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the under ground
>> tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals. Then they lie to us
>> saying they only make penny's on the gal profit,bullshit!
>
> I was quite pleasantly surprised yesterday (after getting over the shock
> of how much everyone was raising prices) by the behavior of my towns local
> Mobil station.
>
> Yesterday afternoon, the Gulf on the corner raised it's prices to $2.999.
> I was in the Cumberland Farms a few doors down getting a few items when I
> noticed the line, 20 cars long for the Mobil station. When I asked the
> clerk of the store I was in what was going on, he told me the owner of the
> Mobil station stated he was not going to change his price ($2.699) until
> his tanks ran dry, then raise his price to match what his next refill cost
> him. I thought that was admirable. Today he has cones up blocking his
> pumps as he is empty.
>
> So I continued on my way, and a half mile down the road I passed the local
> Stewart's Shop. They are usually one of the cheapest places around.
> Their price was already bumped up to $3.299.
>
> On my way home later that night, the above mentioned Gulf station was up
> to $3.19.
>
> Today, while heading to Home Depot and my buddies bagel shop up in
> Poughkeepsie, I saw EVERY Mobil station on Rt 9 with their price at
> $2.899. On my way home as I passed the same Stewart's Shop their price was
> $3.499. What the hell makes their gas worth $.60 more than Mobil???
>
> So I called my buddy who owned the bagel shop and asked him what prices he
> saw for gas on his way home (he lives in New Paltz). Of the 3 Mobil
> stations, 2 were at $2.999 (including the one right off the exit for the
> NYS Thruway which is usually a little higher than everybody else due to
> it's location) but this 1 Mobil station (on Rt 9W just north of Highland)
> they also had their price cranked up to $3.499.
>
> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
Well, the above mentioned Mobil station has gas once again and their price
is holding at $2.899. The Gulf next door has since raised prices again and
is now at $3.299 as is the Sunoco up the road. The Stewart's Shop is still
at $3.499.
09-02-2005, 03:12 PM
#24
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Michael Wojcik" <mwojcik@newsguy.com> wrote in message
news:dfa4co014gq@news4.newsguy.com...
>
> In article <XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny>, "Seth"
> <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> writes:
>>
>> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
>
> I see no great mystery here.
>
> - Gas is sometimes sold as a loss leader, particularly by stations
> attached to convenience stores, as the profit margins for convenience
> stores are relatively generous.
Well, this station doesn't have a "Mobil on the Run", just a cash office
that sells smokes, soda and gum.
> - A gas station owner with some cash to burn might well embark on a
> little price war, particularly when prices peak, to put some pressure
> on competitors.
Yesh, I've seen that at a nickel. But it being all the Mobils in this area,
I wonder if Mobil home office is doing some subsidy.
> - During a surge in gas prices, it may be profitable in the long run
> to sell gas at a loss in order to build customer loyalty.
Well, with all the small margins people have been quoting that gas stations
have, that's just too big a loss for me to accept this as a reason.
> These all boil down to the simple principle that it sometimes makes
> economic sense to sell a product at a loss for a short period.
See above comment.
> Happens all the time, and a "crisis" is an ideal time to do it, since
> you get free advertising from media attention and word of mouth.
This also leads me to think Mobil Corp may be behind the price hold of the
Mobil stations. Just too many of them under different management to not be
organized on a larger scale.
news:dfa4co014gq@news4.newsguy.com...
>
> In article <XKQRe.6090$cg.5343@news02.roc.ny>, "Seth"
> <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> writes:
>>
>> Some serious disparity to prices within a small distance of each other.
>
> I see no great mystery here.
>
> - Gas is sometimes sold as a loss leader, particularly by stations
> attached to convenience stores, as the profit margins for convenience
> stores are relatively generous.
Well, this station doesn't have a "Mobil on the Run", just a cash office
that sells smokes, soda and gum.
> - A gas station owner with some cash to burn might well embark on a
> little price war, particularly when prices peak, to put some pressure
> on competitors.
Yesh, I've seen that at a nickel. But it being all the Mobils in this area,
I wonder if Mobil home office is doing some subsidy.
> - During a surge in gas prices, it may be profitable in the long run
> to sell gas at a loss in order to build customer loyalty.
Well, with all the small margins people have been quoting that gas stations
have, that's just too big a loss for me to accept this as a reason.
> These all boil down to the simple principle that it sometimes makes
> economic sense to sell a product at a loss for a short period.
See above comment.
> Happens all the time, and a "crisis" is an ideal time to do it, since
> you get free advertising from media attention and word of mouth.
This also leads me to think Mobil Corp may be behind the price hold of the
Mobil stations. Just too many of them under different management to not be
organized on a larger scale.
09-02-2005, 03:22 PM
#25
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Seth" <seth_lermanNOSPAM@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news
v1Se.6890$OT1.293@fe09.lga...
>
>> Happens all the time, and a "crisis" is an ideal time to do it, since
>> you get free advertising from media attention and word of mouth.
>
> This also leads me to think Mobil Corp may be behind the price hold of the
> Mobil stations. Just too many of them under different management to not
> be organized on a larger scale.
Yup, appears to be coming from home office. Found a press release that
confirms it.
http://tinyurl.com/agmxa
What I found to be the most relevant part of the release (in regards to this
thread)...
"
ExxonMobil is making branded fuel available to its independent retailers and
distributors at wholesale prices below the spot market and NYMEX gasoline
prices. The vast majority of Exxon and Mobil service stations are operated
by individual dealers and distributors who purchase their fuel products from
ExxonMobil and set their own retail prices.
"
It appears that many (at least here in my area) are going along with
ExxonMobil's wishes.
news
v1Se.6890$OT1.293@fe09.lga...>
>> Happens all the time, and a "crisis" is an ideal time to do it, since
>> you get free advertising from media attention and word of mouth.
>
> This also leads me to think Mobil Corp may be behind the price hold of the
> Mobil stations. Just too many of them under different management to not
> be organized on a larger scale.
Yup, appears to be coming from home office. Found a press release that
confirms it.
http://tinyurl.com/agmxa
What I found to be the most relevant part of the release (in regards to this
thread)...
"
ExxonMobil is making branded fuel available to its independent retailers and
distributors at wholesale prices below the spot market and NYMEX gasoline
prices. The vast majority of Exxon and Mobil service stations are operated
by individual dealers and distributors who purchase their fuel products from
ExxonMobil and set their own retail prices.
"
It appears that many (at least here in my area) are going along with
ExxonMobil's wishes.
09-02-2005, 05:14 PM
#26
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
Waiving the right to remain silent, "TeGGeR®" <tegger@tegger.c0m>
said:
> Yeah, sort of like your own household finances. If you take home
> $60,000 per year, and you spent $54,600 during that year, your
> profit is $5,400. (That's about the same percentages as Exxon
> had last year, by the way.)
Not a perfect analogy, but close enough...
> With this profit, you can pay off some of the mortgage, buy a
> new TV, go on a vacation, get your kid braces, fix the roof,
> build a fence, all sorts of stuff. That's what profit is for.
Some of the things you mention here are acually expenses, to be taken
BEFORE your "profit" is calculated - such as building that fence.
--
Larry J. - Remove spamtrap in ALLCAPS to e-mail
The United States is the greatest country in the world..!
Eleven million illegal aliens can't be wrong.
said:
> Yeah, sort of like your own household finances. If you take home
> $60,000 per year, and you spent $54,600 during that year, your
> profit is $5,400. (That's about the same percentages as Exxon
> had last year, by the way.)
Not a perfect analogy, but close enough...
> With this profit, you can pay off some of the mortgage, buy a
> new TV, go on a vacation, get your kid braces, fix the roof,
> build a fence, all sorts of stuff. That's what profit is for.
Some of the things you mention here are acually expenses, to be taken
BEFORE your "profit" is calculated - such as building that fence.
--
Larry J. - Remove spamtrap in ALLCAPS to e-mail
The United States is the greatest country in the world..!
Eleven million illegal aliens can't be wrong.
09-02-2005, 08:14 PM
#27
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
TeGGeR® wrote:
> jim beam <nospam@example.net> wrote in
> news:-fGdnUmByMOl8oveRVn-1Q@speakeasy.net:
>
>> twfsa wrote:
>>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and
>>> fills it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to
>>> the public is $1.00 per gal.
>>>
>>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the
>>> 4000 gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>>
>>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining
>>> 1000 gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a
>>> gal, they raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the
>>> under ground tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals.
>>> Then they lie to us saying they only make penny's on the gal
>>> profit,bullshit!
>>>
>>> And thats what they are doing ........most are just raising the
>>> price because the guy next door did.
>>>
>>> Tom
>>
>> dude, the retailer /is/ making pennies. but the /refinery/ has
>> stepped up it's margin to 20%. at $70 per barrel, you do the math.
>>
>> oh, and don't forget that [unnecessary] oxygenates reduce mpg's so
>> you have to buy more of the stuff. and don't forget that we
>> subsidize [oxygenate] ethanol production to the tune of billions of
>> dollars each year. and don't forget that we're also being asked to
>> pay a premium for oxygenated fuel. can you say triple whammy? are
>> we getting gouged? sure! but it ain't the retailer.
>>
>
>
> It ain't the oil companies either. They don't set the prices, the
> markets do. Cartels have some influence on prices by way of
> production control, but the primary movers of oil pricing are
> political and emotional, and are out of oil company control.
>
> Oil companies benefit from a run-up in prices, but do not cause these
> run- ups. Exxon saw its net profit margin increase from 8% in 2003 to
> 9% in 2004 on account of more expensive oil. It's probably up to
> nearly 10% now.
I find it hard to believe that all of the different companies can come up
with the same LOH rate and have the same G&A and operating expenses per
gallon of refined product. One would assume those with the higher volume
would offset the LOH rates lower.
Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the same
relative retail price. Collusion?
> jim beam <nospam@example.net> wrote in
> news:-fGdnUmByMOl8oveRVn-1Q@speakeasy.net:
>
>> twfsa wrote:
>>> If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and
>>> fills it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to
>>> the public is $1.00 per gal.
>>>
>>> A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the
>>> 4000 gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>>
>>> Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining
>>> 1000 gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a
>>> gal, they raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the
>>> under ground tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals.
>>> Then they lie to us saying they only make penny's on the gal
>>> profit,bullshit!
>>>
>>> And thats what they are doing ........most are just raising the
>>> price because the guy next door did.
>>>
>>> Tom
>>
>> dude, the retailer /is/ making pennies. but the /refinery/ has
>> stepped up it's margin to 20%. at $70 per barrel, you do the math.
>>
>> oh, and don't forget that [unnecessary] oxygenates reduce mpg's so
>> you have to buy more of the stuff. and don't forget that we
>> subsidize [oxygenate] ethanol production to the tune of billions of
>> dollars each year. and don't forget that we're also being asked to
>> pay a premium for oxygenated fuel. can you say triple whammy? are
>> we getting gouged? sure! but it ain't the retailer.
>>
>
>
> It ain't the oil companies either. They don't set the prices, the
> markets do. Cartels have some influence on prices by way of
> production control, but the primary movers of oil pricing are
> political and emotional, and are out of oil company control.
>
> Oil companies benefit from a run-up in prices, but do not cause these
> run- ups. Exxon saw its net profit margin increase from 8% in 2003 to
> 9% in 2004 on account of more expensive oil. It's probably up to
> nearly 10% now.
I find it hard to believe that all of the different companies can come up
with the same LOH rate and have the same G&A and operating expenses per
gallon of refined product. One would assume those with the higher volume
would offset the LOH rates lower.
Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the same
relative retail price. Collusion?
09-02-2005, 08:20 PM
#28
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
L Alpert wrote:
> TeGGeR® wrote:
>
>>jim beam <nospam@example.net> wrote in
>>news:-fGdnUmByMOl8oveRVn-1Q@speakeasy.net:
>>
>>
>>>twfsa wrote:
>>>
>>>>If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and
>>>>fills it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to
>>>>the public is $1.00 per gal.
>>>>
>>>>A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the
>>>>4000 gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>>>
>>>>Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining
>>>>1000 gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a
>>>>gal, they raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the
>>>>under ground tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals.
>>>>Then they lie to us saying they only make penny's on the gal
>>>>profit,bullshit!
>>>>
>>>>And thats what they are doing ........most are just raising the
>>>>price because the guy next door did.
>>>>
>>>>Tom
>>>
>>>dude, the retailer /is/ making pennies. but the /refinery/ has
>>>stepped up it's margin to 20%. at $70 per barrel, you do the math.
>>>
>>>oh, and don't forget that [unnecessary] oxygenates reduce mpg's so
>>>you have to buy more of the stuff. and don't forget that we
>>>subsidize [oxygenate] ethanol production to the tune of billions of
>>>dollars each year. and don't forget that we're also being asked to
>>>pay a premium for oxygenated fuel. can you say triple whammy? are
>>>we getting gouged? sure! but it ain't the retailer.
>>>
>>
>>
>>It ain't the oil companies either. They don't set the prices, the
>>markets do. Cartels have some influence on prices by way of
>>production control, but the primary movers of oil pricing are
>>political and emotional, and are out of oil company control.
>>
>>Oil companies benefit from a run-up in prices, but do not cause these
>>run- ups. Exxon saw its net profit margin increase from 8% in 2003 to
>>9% in 2004 on account of more expensive oil. It's probably up to
>>nearly 10% now.
>
>
> I find it hard to believe that all of the different companies can come up
> with the same LOH rate and have the same G&A and operating expenses per
> gallon of refined product. One would assume those with the higher volume
> would offset the LOH rates lower.
funny, ain't it.
>
> Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the same
> relative retail price. Collusion?
omg!!! kill the heretic!!! no, collusion would be illegal...
> TeGGeR® wrote:
>
>>jim beam <nospam@example.net> wrote in
>>news:-fGdnUmByMOl8oveRVn-1Q@speakeasy.net:
>>
>>
>>>twfsa wrote:
>>>
>>>>If a gas station owner has a 4000 gal under ground fuel tank, and
>>>>fills it for lets say a $1 a gal, to make this simple his price to
>>>>the public is $1.00 per gal.
>>>>
>>>>A few days later he figures that there is only 1000 gals left in the
>>>>4000 gal tank so he orders 3000 gals @$2.00 a gal.
>>>>
>>>>Here's where there ing us, instead of selling that remaining
>>>>1000 gals, left over from the initial 4000gal purchase @ a $1.00 a
>>>>gal, they raise there price to $2 a gallon, for everything in the
>>>>under ground tank. They just made 100% profit, on that 1000 gals.
>>>>Then they lie to us saying they only make penny's on the gal
>>>>profit,bullshit!
>>>>
>>>>And thats what they are doing ........most are just raising the
>>>>price because the guy next door did.
>>>>
>>>>Tom
>>>
>>>dude, the retailer /is/ making pennies. but the /refinery/ has
>>>stepped up it's margin to 20%. at $70 per barrel, you do the math.
>>>
>>>oh, and don't forget that [unnecessary] oxygenates reduce mpg's so
>>>you have to buy more of the stuff. and don't forget that we
>>>subsidize [oxygenate] ethanol production to the tune of billions of
>>>dollars each year. and don't forget that we're also being asked to
>>>pay a premium for oxygenated fuel. can you say triple whammy? are
>>>we getting gouged? sure! but it ain't the retailer.
>>>
>>
>>
>>It ain't the oil companies either. They don't set the prices, the
>>markets do. Cartels have some influence on prices by way of
>>production control, but the primary movers of oil pricing are
>>political and emotional, and are out of oil company control.
>>
>>Oil companies benefit from a run-up in prices, but do not cause these
>>run- ups. Exxon saw its net profit margin increase from 8% in 2003 to
>>9% in 2004 on account of more expensive oil. It's probably up to
>>nearly 10% now.
>
>
> I find it hard to believe that all of the different companies can come up
> with the same LOH rate and have the same G&A and operating expenses per
> gallon of refined product. One would assume those with the higher volume
> would offset the LOH rates lower.
funny, ain't it.
>
> Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the same
> relative retail price. Collusion?
omg!!! kill the heretic!!! no, collusion would be illegal...
09-02-2005, 08:53 PM
#29
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"L Alpert" <alpertl@xxgmail.com> wrote in
news:lZCdnTwXW6R0d4XeRVn-iA@comcast.com:
>
> Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the
> same relative retail price. Collusion?
>
>
>
>
No, just that operating margins are about as low as they can go.
There IS a floor, you know. People forget this. They tend to think that if
prices are not highly variable for a commodity, that the suppliers are
colluding.
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
news:lZCdnTwXW6R0d4XeRVn-iA@comcast.com:
>
> Yet, when one drives down the street, company a,b and c all have the
> same relative retail price. Collusion?
>
>
>
>
No, just that operating margins are about as low as they can go.
There IS a floor, you know. People forget this. They tend to think that if
prices are not highly variable for a commodity, that the suppliers are
colluding.
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
09-02-2005, 08:56 PM
#30
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Price Gougeing
"Larry J." <usenet2@DE.LETE.THISljvideo.com> wrote in
news:Xns96C591393AE3larrythefrog@68.6.19.6:
> Waiving the right to remain silent, "TeGGeR®" <tegger@tegger.c0m>
> said:
>
>> Yeah, sort of like your own household finances. If you take home
>> $60,000 per year, and you spent $54,600 during that year, your
>> profit is $5,400. (That's about the same percentages as Exxon
>> had last year, by the way.)
>
> Not a perfect analogy, but close enough...
>
>> With this profit, you can pay off some of the mortgage, buy a
>> new TV, go on a vacation, get your kid braces, fix the roof,
>> build a fence, all sorts of stuff. That's what profit is for.
>
> Some of the things you mention here are acually expenses, to be taken
> BEFORE your "profit" is calculated - such as building that fence.
>
Depends on your jurisdiction. Canada does not allow mortgages, roofs, or
fences as personal tax deductions. Even your kid's braces are not
deductible if you make over about $25,000 per year net.
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
news:Xns96C591393AE3larrythefrog@68.6.19.6:
> Waiving the right to remain silent, "TeGGeR®" <tegger@tegger.c0m>
> said:
>
>> Yeah, sort of like your own household finances. If you take home
>> $60,000 per year, and you spent $54,600 during that year, your
>> profit is $5,400. (That's about the same percentages as Exxon
>> had last year, by the way.)
>
> Not a perfect analogy, but close enough...
>
>> With this profit, you can pay off some of the mortgage, buy a
>> new TV, go on a vacation, get your kid braces, fix the roof,
>> build a fence, all sorts of stuff. That's what profit is for.
>
> Some of the things you mention here are acually expenses, to be taken
> BEFORE your "profit" is calculated - such as building that fence.
>
Depends on your jurisdiction. Canada does not allow mortgages, roofs, or
fences as personal tax deductions. Even your kid's braces are not
deductible if you make over about $25,000 per year net.
--
TeGGeR®
The Unofficial Honda/Acura FAQ
www.tegger.com/hondafaq/
