|
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
"lastnn30" <lastnn30@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<g3XTa.69294$zwL.49489@news04.bloor.is.net.ca ble.rogers.com>...
> Question, I have Honda Civic 2001 (47500km) I have never tested the old of > the transition (5 speed transmission). Now when I try to change the shift > from lets say 1 to 2 or 3 to 4 etc I feel it is not smooth. Do you think I > should do something? Do you think the oil need to be changed/add ? when the > transmission oil should be change/add usually. Thanks. Change the transmission oil. The safe choice is the Honda MTF but many people (myself included) use Red Line MTL. 10W30 motor oil was spec'd for years but it was never a good choice to lubricate a syncromesh transmission. If your dealership doesn't have the Honda MTF, you can get it at www.manhonda.com or other on-line retailers. --- Bror Jace |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
Bror Jace wrote: > > "lastnn30" <lastnn30@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<g3XTa.69294$zwL.49489@news04.bloor.is.net.ca ble.rogers.com>... > > Question, I have Honda Civic 2001 (47500km) I have never tested the old of > > the transition (5 speed transmission). Now when I try to change the shift > > from lets say 1 to 2 or 3 to 4 etc I feel it is not smooth. Do you think I > > should do something? Do you think the oil need to be changed/add ? when the > > transmission oil should be change/add usually. Thanks. > > Change the transmission oil. The safe choice is the Honda MTF but many > people (myself included) use Red Line MTL. 10W30 motor oil was spec'd > for years but it was never a good choice to lubricate a syncromesh > transmission. > > If your dealership doesn't have the Honda MTF, you can get it at > www.manhonda.com or other on-line retailers. > > --- Bror Jace Once you use RedLine, you'll never go back to anything else. Been running the stuff in my old cars for years... -- Regards, JT (Residing in Austin, Texas) 1931 Studebaker President State Coupe (Q4) - Big Big Project 1955 Studebaker President State Coupe 1955 Studebaker President State Sedan 1956 Studebaker Power Hawk - Long Time Fun Car - (Will be burial container) 1963 Studebaker Lark Custom 4 Door Sedan 1964 Studebaker Champ P/U T-6 Long Bed 1965 Honda Dream 305 1989 Honda CRX 1956 Leica M2 |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
Bror Jace wrote: > > "lastnn30" <lastnn30@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<g3XTa.69294$zwL.49489@news04.bloor.is.net.ca ble.rogers.com>... > > Question, I have Honda Civic 2001 (47500km) I have never tested the old of > > the transition (5 speed transmission). Now when I try to change the shift > > from lets say 1 to 2 or 3 to 4 etc I feel it is not smooth. Do you think I > > should do something? Do you think the oil need to be changed/add ? when the > > transmission oil should be change/add usually. Thanks. > > Change the transmission oil. The safe choice is the Honda MTF but many > people (myself included) use Red Line MTL. 10W30 motor oil was spec'd > for years but it was never a good choice to lubricate a syncromesh > transmission. > > If your dealership doesn't have the Honda MTF, you can get it at > www.manhonda.com or other on-line retailers. > > --- Bror Jace Once you use RedLine, you'll never go back to anything else. Been running the stuff in my old cars for years... -- Regards, JT (Residing in Austin, Texas) 1931 Studebaker President State Coupe (Q4) - Big Big Project 1955 Studebaker President State Coupe 1955 Studebaker President State Sedan 1956 Studebaker Power Hawk - Long Time Fun Car - (Will be burial container) 1963 Studebaker Lark Custom 4 Door Sedan 1964 Studebaker Champ P/U T-6 Long Bed 1965 Honda Dream 305 1989 Honda CRX 1956 Leica M2 |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the
plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg -- Charles Tague 93 Honda Civic DX HB 1.6L SOHC VTEC 14.85 @ 89 mph,1.98 60 ft. With ZEX 85 hp ZEX 13.09 @ 103 mph, 1.81 60ft. 86 Pontiac Trans Am 225/50/15 GForce Drag Radials 305 peanut cammed 15.29 @ 88 mph http://home.cinci.rr.com/mistab0ne/ "JETman" <jetassoc@worldnet.att.net> wrote in message news:3F21E70D.62EBCA56@worldnet.att.net... > > > Bror Jace wrote: > > > > "lastnn30" <lastnn30@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<g3XTa.69294$zwL.49489@news04.bloor.is.net.ca ble.rogers.com>... > > > Question, I have Honda Civic 2001 (47500km) I have never tested the old of > > > the transition (5 speed transmission). Now when I try to change the shift > > > from lets say 1 to 2 or 3 to 4 etc I feel it is not smooth. Do you think I > > > should do something? Do you think the oil need to be changed/add ? when the > > > transmission oil should be change/add usually. Thanks. > > > > Change the transmission oil. The safe choice is the Honda MTF but many > > people (myself included) use Red Line MTL. 10W30 motor oil was spec'd > > for years but it was never a good choice to lubricate a syncromesh > > transmission. > > > > If your dealership doesn't have the Honda MTF, you can get it at > > www.manhonda.com or other on-line retailers. > > > > --- Bror Jace > > > > Once you use RedLine, you'll never go back to anything else. Been > running the stuff in my old cars for years... > > > -- > Regards, > > JT (Residing in Austin, Texas) > > > 1931 Studebaker President State Coupe (Q4) - Big Big Project > 1955 Studebaker President State Coupe > 1955 Studebaker President State Sedan > 1956 Studebaker Power Hawk - Long Time Fun Car - (Will be burial > container) > 1963 Studebaker Lark Custom 4 Door Sedan > 1964 Studebaker Champ P/U T-6 Long Bed > 1965 Honda Dream 305 > 1989 Honda CRX > 1956 Leica M2 |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the
plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg -- Charles Tague 93 Honda Civic DX HB 1.6L SOHC VTEC 14.85 @ 89 mph,1.98 60 ft. With ZEX 85 hp ZEX 13.09 @ 103 mph, 1.81 60ft. 86 Pontiac Trans Am 225/50/15 GForce Drag Radials 305 peanut cammed 15.29 @ 88 mph http://home.cinci.rr.com/mistab0ne/ "JETman" <jetassoc@worldnet.att.net> wrote in message news:3F21E70D.62EBCA56@worldnet.att.net... > > > Bror Jace wrote: > > > > "lastnn30" <lastnn30@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<g3XTa.69294$zwL.49489@news04.bloor.is.net.ca ble.rogers.com>... > > > Question, I have Honda Civic 2001 (47500km) I have never tested the old of > > > the transition (5 speed transmission). Now when I try to change the shift > > > from lets say 1 to 2 or 3 to 4 etc I feel it is not smooth. Do you think I > > > should do something? Do you think the oil need to be changed/add ? when the > > > transmission oil should be change/add usually. Thanks. > > > > Change the transmission oil. The safe choice is the Honda MTF but many > > people (myself included) use Red Line MTL. 10W30 motor oil was spec'd > > for years but it was never a good choice to lubricate a syncromesh > > transmission. > > > > If your dealership doesn't have the Honda MTF, you can get it at > > www.manhonda.com or other on-line retailers. > > > > --- Bror Jace > > > > Once you use RedLine, you'll never go back to anything else. Been > running the stuff in my old cars for years... > > > -- > Regards, > > JT (Residing in Austin, Texas) > > > 1931 Studebaker President State Coupe (Q4) - Big Big Project > 1955 Studebaker President State Coupe > 1955 Studebaker President State Sedan > 1956 Studebaker Power Hawk - Long Time Fun Car - (Will be burial > container) > 1963 Studebaker Lark Custom 4 Door Sedan > 1964 Studebaker Champ P/U T-6 Long Bed > 1965 Honda Dream 305 > 1989 Honda CRX > 1956 Leica M2 |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
"Mista Bone" <MistaB0ne@cinci.rr.com> wrote in message news:<UrmUa.6774$dO2.226@fe2.columbus.rr.com>...
> I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the > plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. > > http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg Bone, is that a shot of that RSX tranny you've posted before? I know you've never been a fan of the Red Line gear oils but I've used them with great results in a '90 Integra and my '95 Civic Coupe. Combined, those two cars racked up 220,000 miles with me as a driver and another 100,000+ with others at the wheel. Great shifting, no problems. If you're right about the MTL eating a plastic seal, that's pretty sad for Honda. They should know better than to put such a finicky seal in their tranny when so many people use the Red Line synchromesh fluids. They've been around for well over a decade. But if I had an RSX, I'd rather be safe than sorry and use the not-particularly-impressive Honda MTF. Oh well. --- Bror Jace For the best in oil & lubrication discussion try: http://theoildrop.server101.com/cgi/ultimatebb.cgi |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
"Mista Bone" <MistaB0ne@cinci.rr.com> wrote in message news:<UrmUa.6774$dO2.226@fe2.columbus.rr.com>...
> I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the > plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. > > http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg Bone, is that a shot of that RSX tranny you've posted before? I know you've never been a fan of the Red Line gear oils but I've used them with great results in a '90 Integra and my '95 Civic Coupe. Combined, those two cars racked up 220,000 miles with me as a driver and another 100,000+ with others at the wheel. Great shifting, no problems. If you're right about the MTL eating a plastic seal, that's pretty sad for Honda. They should know better than to put such a finicky seal in their tranny when so many people use the Red Line synchromesh fluids. They've been around for well over a decade. But if I had an RSX, I'd rather be safe than sorry and use the not-particularly-impressive Honda MTF. Oh well. --- Bror Jace For the best in oil & lubrication discussion try: http://theoildrop.server101.com/cgi/ultimatebb.cgi |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
On 27 Jul 2003 18:21:54 -0700, brorjace@hotmail.com (Bror Jace) wrote:
>"Mista Bone" <MistaB0ne@cinci.rr.com> wrote in message news:<UrmUa.6774$dO2.226@fe2.columbus.rr.com>... >> I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the >> plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. >> >> http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg > >Bone, is that a shot of that RSX tranny you've posted before? > >I know you've never been a fan of the Red Line gear oils but I've used >them with great results in a '90 Integra and my '95 Civic Coupe. >Combined, those two cars racked up 220,000 miles with me as a driver >and another 100,000+ with others at the wheel. Great shifting, no >problems. > >If you're right about the MTL eating a plastic seal, that's pretty sad >for Honda. They should know better than to put such a finicky seal in >their tranny when so many people use the Red Line synchromesh fluids. >They've been around for well over a decade. It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are jammed against each other in the bad bearing. >But if I had an RSX, I'd rather be safe than sorry and use the >not-particularly-impressive Honda MTF. Oh well. The Honda MTF works fine for me. Rgds, George Macdonald "Just because they're paranoid doesn't mean you're not psychotic" - Who, me?? |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
On 27 Jul 2003 18:21:54 -0700, brorjace@hotmail.com (Bror Jace) wrote:
>"Mista Bone" <MistaB0ne@cinci.rr.com> wrote in message news:<UrmUa.6774$dO2.226@fe2.columbus.rr.com>... >> I'll never use Redline MTL in a Honda tranny again. It eats away at the >> plastic bearing cage for the input shaft bearing. >> >> http://www.codyscafe.com/~mrbone/pic...goodbadISB.jpg > >Bone, is that a shot of that RSX tranny you've posted before? > >I know you've never been a fan of the Red Line gear oils but I've used >them with great results in a '90 Integra and my '95 Civic Coupe. >Combined, those two cars racked up 220,000 miles with me as a driver >and another 100,000+ with others at the wheel. Great shifting, no >problems. > >If you're right about the MTL eating a plastic seal, that's pretty sad >for Honda. They should know better than to put such a finicky seal in >their tranny when so many people use the Red Line synchromesh fluids. >They've been around for well over a decade. It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are jammed against each other in the bad bearing. >But if I had an RSX, I'd rather be safe than sorry and use the >not-particularly-impressive Honda MTF. Oh well. The Honda MTF works fine for me. Rgds, George Macdonald "Just because they're paranoid doesn't mean you're not psychotic" - Who, me?? |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
fammacd=!SPAM^nothanks@tellurian.com (George Macdonald) wrote in message news:<3f24c261.75946917@news.tellurian.com>...
> It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't > clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got > worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are > jammed against each other in the bad bearing. Was there a big difference between the 5th and 6th generation Civic 5-speeds? My '95 Coupe went 132,000 miles (122,000 miles on MTL) without a single tranny-related problem. If solvency WAS an issue, it surely would have reared its ugly head in my car as I ran it much, much longer. > The Honda MTF works fine for me. I've never tried the stuff. A virgin oil analysis on it shows it to be a fairly ordinary-looking fluid. No special anti-wear (moly, borate-esters, etc ...) just a good dose of what looks like ZDDP ... in quantities motor oils used to have the stuff. I just know that MTL (70W80) was a vast improvement over the factory fill in both my '90 Integra as well as the '95 Civic. Who knows what they put in the trannies back then at the factory? What I like most about the Red Line fluids is their cold-shift capabilities. Dead-of-winter graunch is greatly eliminated. In fact, I have to get rid of the crappy factory gear oil in my Sentra Spec-V's 6-speed before this coming winter. The tranny is full of graunch at any temp under 40F until it's thoroughly warm. I have to shift very s l o w l y and c a r e f u l l y until the car is well warmed up to keep from grinding. I figure MT-90 (75W90) will be a significant improvement ... and it's the most popular fluid with other Spec drivers. --- Bror Jace (Saratoga, NY) |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
fammacd=!SPAM^nothanks@tellurian.com (George Macdonald) wrote in message news:<3f24c261.75946917@news.tellurian.com>...
> It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't > clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got > worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are > jammed against each other in the bad bearing. Was there a big difference between the 5th and 6th generation Civic 5-speeds? My '95 Coupe went 132,000 miles (122,000 miles on MTL) without a single tranny-related problem. If solvency WAS an issue, it surely would have reared its ugly head in my car as I ran it much, much longer. > The Honda MTF works fine for me. I've never tried the stuff. A virgin oil analysis on it shows it to be a fairly ordinary-looking fluid. No special anti-wear (moly, borate-esters, etc ...) just a good dose of what looks like ZDDP ... in quantities motor oils used to have the stuff. I just know that MTL (70W80) was a vast improvement over the factory fill in both my '90 Integra as well as the '95 Civic. Who knows what they put in the trannies back then at the factory? What I like most about the Red Line fluids is their cold-shift capabilities. Dead-of-winter graunch is greatly eliminated. In fact, I have to get rid of the crappy factory gear oil in my Sentra Spec-V's 6-speed before this coming winter. The tranny is full of graunch at any temp under 40F until it's thoroughly warm. I have to shift very s l o w l y and c a r e f u l l y until the car is well warmed up to keep from grinding. I figure MT-90 (75W90) will be a significant improvement ... and it's the most popular fluid with other Spec drivers. --- Bror Jace (Saratoga, NY) |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
On 28 Jul 2003 19:46:29 -0700, brorjace@hotmail.com (Bror Jace) wrote:
>fammacd=!SPAM^nothanks@tellurian.com (George Macdonald) wrote in message news:<3f24c261.75946917@news.tellurian.com>... > >> It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't >> clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got >> worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are >> jammed against each other in the bad bearing. > >Was there a big difference between the 5th and 6th generation Civic >5-speeds? My '95 Coupe went 132,000 miles (122,000 miles on MTL) >without a single tranny-related problem. If solvency WAS an issue, it >surely would have reared its ugly head in my car as I ran it much, >much longer. I didn't say it was solvency. Even if it was then I'd indict RedLine before Hionda on the subject of testing and warnings... given your later remarks about Honda MTF. >> The Honda MTF works fine for me. > >I've never tried the stuff. A virgin oil analysis on it shows it to be >a fairly ordinary-looking fluid. No special anti-wear (moly, >borate-esters, etc ...) just a good dose of what looks like ZDDP ... >in quantities motor oils used to have the stuff. I'm not sure how a lubricant/fluid arrives at being characterized as "ordinary-looking"... nor what the "analysis" actually examined. Borate-esters would appear to be something I would not expect to find in Honda MTF, given that they are currently being test marketed by the additive mfrs - maybe something I'd want nothing to do with until that testing is done. Obviously ZDDP works well and has for years and of course, there's no catalytic converter in a gear box - in fact if ZDDP had not been blacklisted by the auto mfrs we'd probably still be using it in our engines and MoDTC would be an obscure chemical. The Honda Australia site used to show the "Honda MTF" with the mention that it was a 75W/80 API gear lubricant - not even sure if it'd be the same stuff - but it was not rated as EP so I'd expect a modest (non-extreme) friction modifier content. >I just know that MTL (70W80) was a vast improvement over the factory >fill in both my '90 Integra as well as the '95 Civic. Who knows what >they put in the trannies back then at the factory? > >What I like most about the Red Line fluids is their cold-shift >capabilities. Dead-of-winter graunch is greatly eliminated. In fact, I >have to get rid of the crappy factory gear oil in my Sentra Spec-V's >6-speed before this coming winter. The tranny is full of graunch at >any temp under 40F until it's thoroughly warm. I have to shift very s >l o w l y and c a r e f u l l y until the car is well warmed up to >keep from grinding. I figure MT-90 (75W90) will be a significant >improvement ... and it's the most popular fluid with other Spec >drivers. Yes with Honda MTF, you *do* have to shift gently in low temps - not for long though - but I expect that Honda is quite sure that it is not incompatible with the metallurgy of their gearbox components. Rgds, George Macdonald "Just because they're paranoid doesn't mean you're not psychotic" - Who, me?? |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
On 28 Jul 2003 19:46:29 -0700, brorjace@hotmail.com (Bror Jace) wrote:
>fammacd=!SPAM^nothanks@tellurian.com (George Macdonald) wrote in message news:<3f24c261.75946917@news.tellurian.com>... > >> It's not the seal that got destroyed - it's the bearing cage and it wasn't >> clear if it suffered due to solvency of the plastic in the oil or if it got >> worn away by abrasion. It's completely gone though - all eight balls are >> jammed against each other in the bad bearing. > >Was there a big difference between the 5th and 6th generation Civic >5-speeds? My '95 Coupe went 132,000 miles (122,000 miles on MTL) >without a single tranny-related problem. If solvency WAS an issue, it >surely would have reared its ugly head in my car as I ran it much, >much longer. I didn't say it was solvency. Even if it was then I'd indict RedLine before Hionda on the subject of testing and warnings... given your later remarks about Honda MTF. >> The Honda MTF works fine for me. > >I've never tried the stuff. A virgin oil analysis on it shows it to be >a fairly ordinary-looking fluid. No special anti-wear (moly, >borate-esters, etc ...) just a good dose of what looks like ZDDP ... >in quantities motor oils used to have the stuff. I'm not sure how a lubricant/fluid arrives at being characterized as "ordinary-looking"... nor what the "analysis" actually examined. Borate-esters would appear to be something I would not expect to find in Honda MTF, given that they are currently being test marketed by the additive mfrs - maybe something I'd want nothing to do with until that testing is done. Obviously ZDDP works well and has for years and of course, there's no catalytic converter in a gear box - in fact if ZDDP had not been blacklisted by the auto mfrs we'd probably still be using it in our engines and MoDTC would be an obscure chemical. The Honda Australia site used to show the "Honda MTF" with the mention that it was a 75W/80 API gear lubricant - not even sure if it'd be the same stuff - but it was not rated as EP so I'd expect a modest (non-extreme) friction modifier content. >I just know that MTL (70W80) was a vast improvement over the factory >fill in both my '90 Integra as well as the '95 Civic. Who knows what >they put in the trannies back then at the factory? > >What I like most about the Red Line fluids is their cold-shift >capabilities. Dead-of-winter graunch is greatly eliminated. In fact, I >have to get rid of the crappy factory gear oil in my Sentra Spec-V's >6-speed before this coming winter. The tranny is full of graunch at >any temp under 40F until it's thoroughly warm. I have to shift very s >l o w l y and c a r e f u l l y until the car is well warmed up to >keep from grinding. I figure MT-90 (75W90) will be a significant >improvement ... and it's the most popular fluid with other Spec >drivers. Yes with Honda MTF, you *do* have to shift gently in low temps - not for long though - but I expect that Honda is quite sure that it is not incompatible with the metallurgy of their gearbox components. Rgds, George Macdonald "Just because they're paranoid doesn't mean you're not psychotic" - Who, me?? |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
George Macdonald wrote:
> Yes with Honda MTF, you *do* have to shift gently in low temps - not for > long though - but I expect that Honda is quite sure that it is not > incompatible with the metallurgy of their gearbox components. > Umm, I think you meant "plasticlurgy" ;) |
Re: 5-speed transmission oil
George Macdonald wrote:
> Yes with Honda MTF, you *do* have to shift gently in low temps - not for > long though - but I expect that Honda is quite sure that it is not > incompatible with the metallurgy of their gearbox components. > Umm, I think you meant "plasticlurgy" ;) |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:23 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands