john.van.v@gmail.com

Hi all,

I have the worst whining sound coming from the rear of the car -- but,
amazingly, nothing is loose. The car is a hatch so it resonates like
nobody's business and I cannot really tell for sure which wheel is
bad. So far I have had 3 of 4 bearings replaced, and I think this is
one that I already replaced.

Do you think I corner too hard on those mountain roads? lf this car
weren't so pretty...

I am going to order the part, but the site doesn't have a picture. I
recall the part that I got from a junk yard, the one that is whining,
was a bolt-in assembly but I am not sure.

I would really be grateful for any hints about this.

Thanks in advance, John

john.van.v@gmail.com

Rev. Tom Wenndt

Be careful here. I had the same sound for the past several weeks on an
Oldsmobile. Had already changed the front bearing/hub assemblies, and was
convinced that this was one of the rears.

Instead, it was diagnosed as cupped and damaged tires as a result of bad
struts. As soon as he said it, my head just dropped, because every GM I
have ever owned has absolutely eaten either shocks or struts. Apparently,
nothing has changed with them.

I suggest you take the car to some kind of mechanic and have him rotate (and
maybe re-balance) the tires. While that is being done, have them spin the
wheels with the car in the air, inspect the tires, and run a general
inspection on the entire car. Firestone Complete Auto Care will run a
thorough inspection along with this for just the cost of the rotation, which
is nothing if you get your tires through them.

That should identify your problem. I'd hate to have you spend money on
items that really don't need replaced.

And BTW, you don't have to have bad struts for one or more of your tires to
start making that kind of noise. A separated belt, cupping, any number of
things will make your tires do that.

Hope this helps.

<john.van.v@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1186788324.173672.316240@q75g2000hsh.googlegr oups.com...
> Hi all,
>
> I have the worst whining sound coming from the rear of the car -- but,
> amazingly, nothing is loose. The car is a hatch so it resonates like
> nobody's business and I cannot really tell for sure which wheel is
> bad. So far I have had 3 of 4 bearings replaced, and I think this is
> one that I already replaced.
>
> Do you think I corner too hard on those mountain roads? lf this car
> weren't so pretty...
>
> I am going to order the part, but the site doesn't have a picture. I
> recall the part that I got from a junk yard, the one that is whining,
> was a bolt-in assembly but I am not sure.
>
> I would really be grateful for any hints about this.
>
> Thanks in advance, John
>
> john.van.v@gmail.com
>

Edwin Pawlowski

"Rev. Tom Wenndt" <trwenndt@grics.net> wrote in message
>
> And BTW, you don't have to have bad struts for one or more of your tires
> to start making that kind of noise. A separated belt, cupping, any number
> of things will make your tires do that.
>
> Hope this helps.

Seems common with FWD car to have cupping (and the associated noise) on the
rear. The rear tires on my '91 Regal could have easily gone 100,000 miles,
but I could not stand the noise any more.

Rev. Tom Wenndt

And sadly, that is my point. It seems that with new struts, you can
minimize the problem, which is what I call a "classic GM-ism". But you'd
better buy some of the best struts available and make sure they have a
lifetime warranty if you are planning on keeping the car for any length of
time, because at some point, one or more of those will have to be replaced
as well.

And even if you do, you will always have to pay labor and an alignment on
them. But as high priced as the struts for my GM are, that still saves a
lot of money.

Have only ever had one Hyundai shock go bad, and it was replaced under
warranty. According to my Hyundai service tech (not the one on this board),
"It doesn't happen very often on these."


"Edwin Pawlowski" <esp@snet.net> wrote in message
news:_Fgvi.49066$YL5.9536@newssvr29.news.prodigy.n et...
>
> "Rev. Tom Wenndt" <trwenndt@grics.net> wrote in message
>>
>> And BTW, you don't have to have bad struts for one or more of your tires
>> to start making that kind of noise. A separated belt, cupping, any
>> number of things will make your tires do that.
>>
>> Hope this helps.
>
> Seems common with FWD car to have cupping (and the associated noise) on
> the rear. The rear tires on my '91 Regal could have easily gone 100,000
> miles, but I could not stand the noise any more.
>

john.van.v@gmail.com

Thanks fellas, but I did hope it would be the tires and tried the
spare on both rears. Plus dis ain't a GM, and has its own odd issues
-- Korean bearings.

Like I said, if she were so damn pretty !!


On Aug 11, 9:18 am, "Rev. Tom Wenndt" <trwen...@grics.net> wrote:
> And sadly, that is my point. It seems that with new struts, you can
> minimize the problem, which is what I call a "classic GM-ism". But you'd
> better buy some of the best struts available and make sure they have a
> lifetime warranty if you are planning on keeping the car for any length of
> time, because at some point, one or more of those will have to be replaced
> as well.
>
> And even if you do, you will always have to pay labor and an alignment on
> them. But as high priced as the struts for my GM are, that still saves a
> lot of money.
>
> Have only ever had one Hyundai shock go bad, and it was replaced under
> warranty. According to my Hyundai service tech (not the one on this board),
> "It doesn't happen very often on these."
>
> "Edwin Pawlowski" <e...@snet.net> wrote in message
>
> news:_Fgvi.49066$YL5.9536@newssvr29.news.prodigy.n et...
>
>
>
> > "Rev. Tom Wenndt" <trwen...@grics.net> wrote in message
>
> >> And BTW, you don't have to have bad struts for one or more of your tires
> >> to start making that kind of noise. A separated belt, cupping, any
> >> number of things will make your tires do that.
>
> >> Hope this helps.
>
> > Seems common with FWD car to have cupping (and the associated noise) on
> > the rear. The rear tires on my '91 Regal could have easily gone 100,000
> > miles, but I could not stand the noise any more.